Strasburg Creamery Menu Handcrafted in Amish Country with Local Cream FLAVORS Vanilla Dutch Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Salted Caramel Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies 'N Cream Brown Butter Sugar Cookie Birthday Cake Cold Brew Coffee Brownie Batter Crunch Old Conestoga Road Dutch Pie The Pierre Railroad Tracks Strawberry Swirl Honey Lemon Lavender Root Beer Carrot Cake Berry Brûlée Blueberry Pie Dairy-Free Vanilla Dairy-Free Peanut